top of page

Vol. 2, Issue 20

Ledgers and Lies

Vol. 2, Issue 20

Noonday Notes

Volume 2 , Issue 20

October 23rd, 2026


In October 2022, Taylor Swift’s Midnights album dropped. I was on medical leave from work and beginning the final descent to my rock bottom. I thought she wrote “Anti-Hero” about me, and I had “Karma” on repeat for a few months until my divorce began then I switched to crying to the “folklore” album while assembling IKEA furniture by myself. Dark times.


If you’ve heard my testimony you know that dark night of the soul led to salvation a few months later. A moment when I felt God’s presence in a way I had never felt before. To be completely honest I haven’t felt it like that since, and lately I have been missing that feeling. It’s tempting to believe the lie that if I self-destruct to a dark place then maybe I will feel Him like that again.


But grace wasn’t a reward for my suffering. It was a gift. Karma is a lie, not just a catchy song. Love shouldn’t be earned by good behavior or withdrawn because of failure. God doesn’t have a ledger when it comes to love.

So I went to the Psalms as any complaining Christian might and read David’s words, “He does not deal with us according to our sins, nor repay us according to our iniquities.” Psalm 103:10


Good behavior doesn’t guarantee good outcomes, just as tragedy doesn’t mean someone deserves what happened to them. Jesus names this in John 9:1–3, when His disciples ask whether a man’s blindness was caused by his own sin or his parents’ sin. Jesus challenges their assumption that suffering must be traced back to someone’s wrongdoing. Life is not a reliable moral scoreboard.


Per usual, the garden reflects this lesson. At Noonday at Grace, our crops are struggling despite what I thought was good soil and compost, consistent watering, and the same care I’m giving the plants at HQ. Maybe there’s too much compost, too much soluble salt, or something else happening in the soil. Stewardship matters, but doing the right things doesn’t ensure the result we want.


I’ve experienced this before, we lost acres of tomatoes to a blight and lettuce to a hail storm at my previous farm. You can do all the right things and still lose a crop. The garden teaches us to pay attention rather than assume we have the whole picture. We can take responsibility for what’s happening without assuming we have complete control over the outcome.


We can tend our soil, take responsibility for our choices, keep showing up and doing the work. But release the ledger, the blame, and the credit. Good things aren’t always rewards, and bad things aren’t always punishments. Covenant love is real, transactional love is a lie.


Where can you stop keeping score in your life and instead love the way God does?


Read the rest of the newsletter here.

bottom of page